Skip to content
Open Daily, 10 AM – 5 PM • Middleton, Wisconsin • 800-438-6878
Open Daily, 10 AM – 5 PM • Middleton, Wisconsin •
800-438-6878

Award Winners

  • Original price $5.95 - Original price $15.95
    Original price
    $5.95 - $15.95
    $5.95 - $15.95
    Current price $5.95

    Kelley's Gourmet Stone Ground Mustard

    in stock

    The 2023 Grand Champion of the World-Wide Mustard Competition. This is a classic yellow deli mustard with a kick of horseradish. Put this on everyt...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
    Original price
    $6.50
    $6.50 - $6.50
    Current price $6.50

    Bucky Badger Honey Mustard Pretzel Dip

    in stock

    A sweet, mild honey mustard that the kids will love. Perfect for dipping pretzels and chicken strips. Ingredients: Brown Sugar, Fructose, Mustard (...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.95 - Original price $6.95
    Original price
    $6.95
    $6.95 - $6.95
    Current price $6.95

    Norman Bishop Dill & Garlic Mustard

    in stock

    This 2002 Grand Champion has the old-fashioned flavor of fresh dill with garlic. Superb for fish, potato salad, deviled eggs, and as a dip for shri...

    View full details
  • Original price $4.50 - Original price $4.50
    Original price
    $4.50
    $4.50 - $4.50
    Current price $4.50

    Pacific Farms Japanese Mustard

    in stock

    Loaded with real wasabi and a seven spice blend, this is what you want for your next sushi plate. Mix it with soy sauce for a spicy sushi dip!Ingre...

    View full details
  • Original price $7.25 - Original price $7.25
    Original price
    $7.25
    $7.25 - $7.25
    Current price $7.25

    Bacik Cossack Mustard with Horseradish and Honey

    in stock

    A spicy Polish condiment. It's great on sandwiches, hot dogs, and kielbasa.Ingredients: Mustard Seeds, Vinegar, Horseradish, Canola Oil, Natural Ho...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.25 - Original price $8.25
    Original price
    $8.25
    $8.25 - $8.25
    Current price $8.25

    Cherchies Hot Banana Pepper Mustard

    in stock

    Chopped sweet-hot banana peppers make this mustard more like a relish. Delicious on brats, pizza, and Italian panini.Ingredients: Water, Vinegar, B...

    View full details
  • Original price $52.00 - Original price $52.00
    Original price
    $52.00
    $52.00 - $52.00
    Current price $52.00

    Award Winners Gift Box

    in stock

    Enjoy award-winning mustards from over the years. Experience why these competition winners stand the taste-test of time.Enclosed in Gift Box:Pommer...

    View full details
  • Original price $7.50 - Original price $7.50
    Original price
    $7.50
    $7.50 - $7.50
    Current price $7.50

    Boetje's Stone Ground Mustard

    in stock

    This Dutch-style grainy brown mustard is the pride of Rock Island, Illinois, and one of the Midwest's great food treasures. It has a strong mustard...

    View full details
  • Original price $5.95 - Original price $5.95
    Original price
    $5.95
    $5.95 - $5.95
    Current price $5.95

    Plochman's Bourbon Mustard

    in stock

    The Grand Champion at the 2018 World-Wide Mustard Competition! The rich flavor of genuine bourbon permeates this spicy brown mustard.Ingredients: S...

    View full details
  • Original price $7.95 - Original price $7.95
    Original price
    $7.95
    $7.95 - $7.95
    Current price $7.95

    Tiger Tail Curry Mustard

    in stock

    Grand Champion of the 2022 World Wide Mustard Competition! This yummy exotic mustard is crafted in small batches in Tennessee and is amazing on pou...

    View full details
  • Original price $7.75 - Original price $7.75
    Original price
    $7.75
    $7.75 - $7.75
    Current price $7.75

    Löwensenf Extra Hot Mustard

    in stock

    A smooth German mustard made with simple ingredients that will deliver a powerful kick to the sinuses. Ingredients: Mustard Seed, Distilled Vinegar...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
    Original price
    $6.50
    $6.50 - $6.50
    Current price $6.50

    Edmond Fallot Horseradish Dijon Mustard

    in stock

    Gold medal winner in the Horseradish category at the 2014 World-Wide Mustard Competition. The French enjoy horseradish as much as we do, but more a...

    View full details
  • Original price $22.00 - Original price $22.00
    Original price
    $22.00
    $22.00 - $22.00
    Current price $22.00

    Pommery Moutarde Royale (Cognac Mustard)

    in stock

    From the maker of the world's most prized grainy mustard comes this glorious Cognac-scented grainy mustard. A rare treat for the serious mustard lo...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.75 - Original price $8.75
    Original price
    $8.75
    $8.75 - $8.75
    Current price $8.75

    Terrapin Ridge Pecan Honey Mustard

    in stock

    The rich flavor of pecans give unique flavor to this honey mustard. A fine accompaniment for cheese or with fried chicken. Silver medal winner in t...

    View full details
  • Original price $2.50 - Original price $9.25
    Original price
    $2.50 - $9.25
    $2.50 - $9.25
    Current price $2.50

    Edmond Fallot Dijon Mustard

    in stock

    2010 Gold Medal Dijon at the World-Wide Mustard Competition. Made in the city of Beaune in the heart of Burgundy. Excellent full flavor, great for ...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
    Original price
    $6.50
    $6.50 - $6.50
    Current price $6.50

    Beaver Cranberry Mustard

    in stock

    Enormous fruit flavor! Great with turkey. Gold medal winner at the 2016 World-Wide Mustard Competition.Ingredients: Water, Sugar, Mustard Seed, Vin...

    View full details
  • Original price $3.25 - Original price $8.25
    Original price
    $3.25 - $8.25
    $3.25 - $8.25
    Current price $3.25

    Raye's Down East Schooner Mustard

    in stock

    2012, 2014, 2015, and 2017 gold medal winner. Who says yellow mustard is boring? This award-winning mustard is a great gourmet treat.Ingredients: D...

    View full details
  • Original price $9.25 - Original price $9.25
    Original price
    $9.25
    $9.25 - $9.25
    Current price $9.25

    Bornier Original Dijon Mustard

    in stock

    Grand Champion of the 2014 and 2020 World-Wide Mustard Competitions. A classic sharp Dijon. Ingredients: Water, Mustard Seeds, Vinegar, Salt, Potas...

    View full details
  • Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
    Original price
    $10.95
    $10.95 - $10.95
    Current price $10.95

    CaJohns Jolokia Ghost Pepper Mustard

    in stock

    Silver medal winner at the 2014 World-Wide Mustard Competition. Red habanero peppers and the legendary Jolokia ghost pepper come together to make t...

    View full details
  • Original price $9.25 - Original price $9.25
    Original price
    $9.25
    $9.25 - $9.25
    Current price $9.25

    Bornier Wholegrain Dijon Mustard

    in stock

    Gold medal winner in the Whole Grain category at the 2015 World-Wide Mustard Competition. Earthy and sharp. We put this on a baked potato and don't...

    View full details
  • Original price $5.25 - Original price $6.95
    Original price
    $5.25 - $6.95
    $5.25 - $6.95
    Current price $5.25

    Plochman's Stone Ground Mustard

    in stock

    This coarse grained mustard won the silver medal in the 2002 Napa Valley Mustard Competition. It also won gold in 1995 and 2000, and bronze in the ...

    View full details
  • Original price $9.25 - Original price $9.25
    Original price
    $9.25
    $9.25 - $9.25
    Current price $9.25

    Daddy Cook's Bleu Cheese Pecan Balsamic Mustard

    in stock

    Savory bleu cheese with the nuttiness of roasted pecans and richness of 18 year aged balsamic vinegar.Ingredients: Stone Ground Mustard (Distilled ...

    View full details
  • Original price $3.95 - Original price $6.75
    Original price
    $3.95 - $6.75
    $3.95 - $6.75
    Current price $3.95

    Willamette Valley Dill Mustard with Honey

    in stock

    At the World-Wide Mustard Competition, this mustard won gold in 2005, silver in 2012, and bronze in 2008. The combination of honey and dill make it...

    View full details
  • Original price $3.50 - Original price $3.50
    Original price
    $3.50
    $3.50 - $3.50
    Current price $3.50

    Beaver Chinese Mustard

    in stock

    Gold medal winner in 2011, 2012, and 2014 at the World-Wide Mustard Competition in the Classic Hot category. Great on egg rolls.Ingredients: Water,...

    View full details
  • Original price $5.95 - Original price $5.95
    Original price
    $5.95
    $5.95 - $5.95
    Current price $5.95

    Plochman's Craft Beer Mustard

    in stock

    Hopped with loads of Amarillo, Citra, and Centennial hops for an undeniably crisp American Pale Ale flavor right from Brickstone Brewery taproom.In...

    View full details
  • Original price $4.75 - Original price $4.75
    Original price
    $4.75
    $4.75 - $4.75
    Current price $4.75

    Plochman's Harvest Honey Mustard

    in stock

    Made with loads of naturally harvested honey, cinnamon, and nutmeg goodness for a high-grade mustard flavor your food will thank you for.Ingredient...

    View full details
  • Original price $3.95 - Original price $3.95
    Original price
    $3.95
    $3.95 - $3.95
    Current price $3.95

    Kosciusko Original Spicy Brown Mustard (Blue Cap)

    in stock

    Kosciusko mustard won gold at the 2014 World-Wide Mustard Competition in the deli category. Its zesty Old World taste goes great with lunch meats, ...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.25 - Original price $6.25
    Original price
    $6.25
    $6.25 - $6.25
    Current price $6.25

    Bertman Original Ball Park Mustard

    in stock

    This award-winning brown mustard is served at Progressive Field (still often called 'The Jake' by long-time fans), home of the Cleveland Guardians....

    View full details
  • Original price $3.95 - Original price $6.75
    Original price
    $3.95 - $6.75
    $3.95 - $6.75
    Current price $3.95

    Haus Barhyte Smoky Garlic Onion Mustard

    in stock

    Gold Medal Garlic Mustard at the 2015 World-Wide Mustard Competition, The garlic, onion, and smoke all come together to create an amazing mustard e...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
    Original price
    $6.50
    $6.50 - $6.50
    Current price $6.50

    Beaver Jalapeño Mustard

    in stock

    Bring on the heat with this gold medal-winning, jalapeño mustard. The recipe is extra hot and will add the perfect jalapeño punch to any sandwich, ...

    View full details
  • Original price $12.95 - Original price $12.95
    Original price
    $12.95
    $12.95 - $12.95
    Current price $12.95

    Aunty Lilikoi Passion Fruit Mustard

    in stock

    A great addition to sandwiches, burgers, and hot dogs. Add to coleslaw or use to top chicken or fish. Gold medal winner in the Fruit category at th...

    View full details
  • Original price $4.50 - Original price $8.75
    Original price
    $4.50 - $8.75
    $4.50 - $8.75
    Current price $4.50

    Sutter Buttes Jalapeño Whiskey Mustard

    in stock

    With a hint of whiskey and a clear jalapeño flavor, this gold medal winner is medium-hot but loaded with flavor. It's a little sweet, a little hot,...

    View full details
  • Original price $5.50 - Original price $5.50
    Original price
    $5.50
    $5.50 - $5.50
    Current price $5.50

    Plochman's The Works Mustard

    in stock

    A chunky mustard with more flavor than most foods can handle. Inspired by a Chicago-style hot dog, these flavors bring it all with every bite.Ingre...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.75 - Original price $6.75
    Original price
    $6.75
    $6.75 - $6.75
    Current price $6.75

    Haus Barhyte Smoky Garlic Mustard

    in stock

    Smooth with a bite — and plenty of smoke and garlic! Mighty terrific on sandwiches or great in your favorite barbecue sauce.Ingredients: Water, Dis...

    View full details
  • Original price $3.95 - Original price $3.95
    Original price
    $3.95
    $3.95 - $3.95
    Current price $3.95

    Silver Spring Everything Bagel Mustard

    in stock

    With sesame seeds, poppy seeds, onion, and garlic, this is just like an everything bagel just without the bagel. Put this on an everything bagel an...

    View full details
  • Original price $7.75 - Original price $7.75
    Original price
    $7.75
    $7.75 - $7.75
    Current price $7.75

    Graham's Dijon Mustard

    in stock

    A potent Dijon mustard, commended for its power and subtlety of flavor in the finish. A great sidekick to all sorts of meats and cheeses! Ingredien...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
    Original price
    $6.50
    $6.50 - $6.50
    Current price $6.50

    Inglehoffer Extra Hot Sriracha Mustard

    in stock

    Gold medal winner in the pepper hot category at the 2015 and 2014 World-Wide Mustard Competition. Not just big heat but big flavor, too. Blend some...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
    Original price
    $6.50
    $6.50 - $6.50
    Current price $6.50

    Inglehoffer Ghost Pepper Mustard

    in stock

    Gold medal winner at the 2016 and 2017 World-Wide Mustard Competition in the Hot Pepper category. Deservedly so. This is some serious pain. You've ...

    View full details
  • Original price $7.95 - Original price $7.95
    Original price
    $7.95
    $7.95 - $7.95
    Current price $7.95

    Clovis Herbs de Provence Mustard

    in stock

    Authentic herbs including basil, oregano, rosemary, and thyme bring bright fresh flavor to grilled meats, fish, and vegetables. Ingredients: Water,...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.95 - Original price $6.95
    Original price
    $6.95
    $6.95 - $6.95
    Current price $6.95

    Woeber's Simply Supreme Honey Mustard

    in stock

    Medal-winning honey mustard at the World-Wide Mustard Competition. Silky smooth texture and a good sharp mustard bite.Ingredients: Sugar, Cider Vin...

    View full details
  • Original price $9.00 - Original price $9.00
    Original price
    $9.00
    $9.00 - $9.00
    Current price $9.00

    Pommery Dijon Mustard

    in stock

    Silver medal winner in the Dijon category at the 2014 World-Wide Mustard Competition. The makers of Pommery Moutarde de Meaux, one of the most reve...

    View full details
  • Original price $10.50 - Original price $10.50
    Original price
    $10.50
    $10.50 - $10.50
    Current price $10.50

    Stormin' Sauce by Gorman Thomas

    in stock

    Gorman Thomas was the American League home run champ in 1979 and 1982, and he brings his South Carolina roots to Wisconsin with this sassy mustard-...

    View full details
  • Original price $9.00 - Original price $9.00
    Original price
    $9.00
    $9.00 - $9.00
    Current price $9.00

    Pommery Fine Herb Mustard

    in stock

    The makers of Pommery Moutarde de Meaux, one of the most revered grainy mustards in the world, also make a delightful new fine herb mustard. Smooth...

    View full details
  • Original price $5.95 - Original price $5.95
    Original price
    $5.95
    $5.95 - $5.95
    Current price $5.95

    Plochman's Cuban Style Mustard

    in stock

    A hint of garlic, a touch of citrus, and white wine give this yellow mustard a unique Cuban-style flavor. Use it to add spice to roast pork sandwic...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
    Original price
    $6.50
    $6.50 - $6.50
    Current price $6.50

    Inglehoffer Sweet-Hot Mustard with Honey

    in stock

    Like it spicy? Like it sweet? Why choose one when you can have both? Inglehoffer Sweet Hot Mustard is made with a blend of spices and organic honey...

    View full details
  • Original price $12.95 - Original price $12.95
    Original price
    $12.95
    $12.95 - $12.95
    Current price $12.95

    Aunty Lilikoi Passion Fruit Habanero Mustard

    in stock

    Grand Champion at the 2006 World-Wide Mustard Competition. Fruity, with just the right amount of heat.Ingredients: Mustard (Vinegar, Mustard Seed, ...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.50 - Original price $8.50
    Original price
    $8.50
    $8.50 - $8.50
    Current price $8.50

    Honeycup Uniquely Sharp Mustard

    in stock

    Gold medal winner in the honey mustard category of the 2021 World-Wide Mustard Competition. This sweet-hot mustard with brown sugar and honey has b...

    View full details
  • Original price $7.75 - Original price $7.75
    Original price
    $7.75
    $7.75 - $7.75
    Current price $7.75

    Graham's Steak Mustard

    Out of stock

    A first-class accompaniment to steak. With 10% tarragon, it's a distinctive yet subtle addition to an already tasty mustard! Ingredients: Mustard S...

    View full details