Skip to content
Open Daily, 10 AM – 5 PM • Middleton, Wisconsin • 800-438-6878
Open Daily, 10 AM – 5 PM • Middleton, Wisconsin •
800-438-6878

Exotic Mustard

  • Original price $4.50 - Original price $4.50
    Original price
    $4.50
    $4.50 - $4.50
    Current price $4.50

    Pacific Farms Japanese Mustard

    in stock

    Loaded with real wasabi and a seven spice blend, this is what you want for your next sushi plate. Mix it with soy sauce for a spicy sushi dip!Ingre...

    View full details
  • Original price $9.25 - Original price $9.25
    Original price
    $9.25
    $9.25 - $9.25
    Current price $9.25

    Daddy Cook's Exotic Ginger Curry Mustard

    in stock

    This boldly spiced mustard will blow you away with its rich Indian-style flavors. Perfect for lamb and fish.Ingredients: Mustard (Distilled Vinegar...

    View full details
  • Original price $5.95 - Original price $5.95
    Original price
    $5.95
    $5.95 - $5.95
    Current price $5.95

    Sprecher Root Beer Mustard

    in stock

    Made with one of America's favorite root beers, this is one funky mustard. We like it on hot dogs and pulled pork.Ingredients: Vinegar, Water, Brow...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
    Original price
    $6.50
    $6.50 - $6.50
    Current price $6.50

    Edmond Fallot Walnut Dijon Mustard

    in stock

    Seriously spectacular 'Moutarde aux Noix' from one of France's most renowned small mustard makers. We've visited the factory in Beaune and can atte...

    View full details
  • Original price $4.95 - Original price $7.95
    Original price
    $4.95 - $7.95
    $4.95 - $7.95
    Current price $4.95

    Stonewall Kitchen Blue Cheese Herb Mustard

    in stock

    If you like blue cheese, you'll love this rich mustard loaded with herbs and pungent blue cheese. This is a fine accompaniment for steaks but goes ...

    View full details
  • Original price $7.95 - Original price $7.95
    Original price
    $7.95
    $7.95 - $7.95
    Current price $7.95

    Tiger Tail Curry Mustard

    in stock

    Grand Champion of the 2022 World Wide Mustard Competition! This yummy exotic mustard is crafted in small batches in Tennessee and is amazing on pou...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
    Original price
    $8.95
    $8.95 - $8.95
    Current price $8.95

    Dr Pete's Praline Mustard Glaze

    in stock

    This sweet syrupy blend of mustard flour, brown sugar, spices, and pecan pieces makes the perfect glaze for a baked ham, acorn squash, sweet potato...

    View full details
  • Original price $4.95 - Original price $7.95
    Original price
    $4.95 - $7.95
    $4.95 - $7.95
    Current price $4.95

    Stonewall Kitchen Maine Maple Champagne Mustard

    in stock

    Rich maple flavor and a bold champagne backbone. Infused with maple, this mustard is splendid combined with fresh breadcrumbs, minced garlic, and p...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.75 - Original price $8.75
    Original price
    $8.75
    $8.75 - $8.75
    Current price $8.75

    Terrapin Ridge Smokey Maple Bacon Mustard

    in stock

    Maple flavor and bacon are added to bold mustard to create a unique and extraordinary condiment. Glaze chicken, ham, or pork with this sweet and ta...

    View full details
  • Original price $4.95 - Original price $11.95
    Original price
    $4.95 - $11.95
    $4.95 - $11.95
    Current price $4.95

    Burnt & Salty Korean Mustard

    in stock

    Congratulations on discovering one of the most unique, versatile condiments on the market. Perk up your sandwiches, eggs, and pizza. Keep it close,...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.75 - Original price $18.00
    Original price
    $6.75 - $18.00
    $6.75 - $18.00
    Current price $6.75

    Slimm & Nunne Maple Peppercorn Mustard

    in stock

    Ingredients: Water, Vinegars (White Distilled, White Wine, and Red Wine), Mustard Seed, White Wine, Sugar, Salt, Natural Maple Flavor With Other Na...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
    Original price
    $8.95
    $8.95 - $8.95
    Current price $8.95

    Delicae Gourmet Lavender Wine Mustard

    in stock

    This wonderful mustard has a fabulous lavender flavor, making it great as a glaze. Try it on poultry, meat, pork, and fish. Great on a ham or corne...

    View full details
  • Original price $9.25 - Original price $9.25
    Original price
    $9.25
    $9.25 - $9.25
    Current price $9.25

    Daddy Cook's Bleu Cheese Pecan Balsamic Mustard

    in stock

    Savory bleu cheese with the nuttiness of roasted pecans and richness of 18 year aged balsamic vinegar.Ingredients: Stone Ground Mustard (Distilled ...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
    Original price
    $8.95
    $8.95 - $8.95
    Current price $8.95

    AJ's Walla Walla Sweet Onion Mustard with Bacon

    in stock

    Smoky onion, bacon, and mustard — totally wild! Wake up your burgers or any sandwich. It also makes a great chip dip when blended with sour cream.

  • Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
    Original price
    $8.95
    $8.95 - $8.95
    Current price $8.95

    Delicae Gourmet Bourbon Bacon Mustard

    in stock

    A sweet, salty, smoky mustard with the flavors of bourbon, maple syrup, and bacon. Fabulous on sandwiches and burgers. Serve over smoked sausages o...

    View full details
  • Original price $37.00 - Original price $37.00
    Original price
    $37.00
    $37.00 - $37.00
    Current price $37.00

    Triple Walnut Salad Gift Box

    in stock

    Now you can make Mrs. Mustard's Famous Triple Walnut Salad at home with these three key ingredients:Cuisine Perel Late Harvest Riesling VinegarInte...

    View full details
  • Original price $13.95 - Original price $13.95
    Original price
    $13.95
    $13.95 - $13.95
    Current price $13.95

    Maison Pebeyre Dijon Mustard with Truffle

    in stock

    This Dijon mustard contains 1.1% black truffle. It's a must-have condiment for burgers and steaks, and it makes a great salad vinaigrette. Ingredie...

    View full details
  • Original price $7.95 - Original price $7.95
    Original price
    $7.95
    $7.95 - $7.95
    Current price $7.95

    Stonewall Kitchen Bourbon Molasses Mustard

    in stock

    A little bourbon, a little molasses, a little mustard, and whole mustard seeds — a perfect glaze for a baked ham, turkey, and even roasted root veg...

    View full details
  • Original price $3.95 - Original price $3.95
    Original price
    $3.95
    $3.95 - $3.95
    Current price $3.95

    Silver Spring Everything Bagel Mustard

    in stock

    With sesame seeds, poppy seeds, onion, and garlic, this is just like an everything bagel just without the bagel. Put this on an everything bagel an...

    View full details
  • Original price $7.95 - Original price $7.95
    Original price
    $7.95
    $7.95 - $7.95
    Current price $7.95

    Butternut Mountain Farm Sweet Maple Mustard

    Out of stock

    This sweet yellow mustard is rich with pure Vermont maple syrup and still quite tangy. Add to canned baked beans and heat until sauce thickens — ab...

    View full details
  • Original price $12.95 - Original price $12.95
    Original price
    $12.95
    $12.95 - $12.95
    Current price $12.95

    Aunty Lilikoi Passion Fruit Habanero Mustard

    in stock

    Grand Champion at the 2006 World-Wide Mustard Competition. Fruity, with just the right amount of heat.Ingredients: Mustard (Vinegar, Mustard Seed, ...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
    Original price
    $8.95
    $8.95 - $8.95
    Current price $8.95

    Delicae Gourmet Mango Curry Mustard

    in stock

    The spice of Indian curry blended with sweet tropical mango is terrific with chicken and fish. Fantastic as a sandwich spread.Ingredients: Mustard ...

    View full details
  • Original price $25.00 - Original price $25.00
    Original price
    $25.00
    $25.00 - $25.00
    Current price $25.00

    Pommery Truffle Mustard

    in stock

    This fine alliance of Pommery mustard and black truffle will satisfy all of your senses. The truffle notes will reveal all of the subtleties of thi...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
    Original price
    $6.50
    $6.50 - $6.50
    Current price $6.50

    Edmond Fallot Honey & Gingerbread Dijon Mustard

    in stock

    The flavor of this mustard is almost as rich as the history of the ingredients that make it. Gingerbread is one of the specialties of the Burgundy ...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
    Original price
    $6.50
    $6.50 - $6.50
    Current price $6.50

    Inglehoffer Applewood Smoked Bacon Mustard

    in stock

    This mustard has a unique, delicious flavor that pairs well with any hot dog, sandwich, or burger. If you like bacon, you'll like this mustard.Ingr...

    View full details
  • Original price $9.25 - Original price $9.25
    Original price
    $9.25
    $9.25 - $9.25
    Current price $9.25

    Daddy Cook's Toasted Sesame Mustard

    in stock

    Slightly sweet with nutty sesame and soy sauce. This mustard makes a great dip for sugar snap peas and egg rolls. Use it to stir-fry chicken.Ingred...

    View full details
  • Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
    Original price
    $9.95
    $9.95 - $9.95
    Current price $9.95

    Tait Farm Ginger Mustard

    in stock

    The mellow sweetness of pears combined with the piquant flavor of ginger and mustard creates a uniquely sensational taste. This ginger mustard is d...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.75 - Original price $8.75
    Original price
    $8.75
    $8.75 - $8.75
    Current price $8.75

    Terrapin Ridge Raspberry Wasabi Mustard

    in stock

    A nice wasabi kick and sweet raspberry puree are blended with a creamy mustard to create a velvety condiment perfect for dipping finger foods or to...

    View full details
  • Original price $7.95 - Original price $7.95
    Original price
    $7.95
    $7.95 - $7.95
    Current price $7.95

    Butternut Mountain Farm Maple Horseradish Mustard

    in stock

    Sweet maple plus spicy horseradish make this unique mustard perfect for glazes and sandwiches.Ingredients: Vinegar, Mustard Seed, Maple Syrup, Hors...

    View full details
  • Original price $12.95 - Original price $12.95
    Original price
    $12.95
    $12.95 - $12.95
    Current price $12.95

    Aunty Lilikoi Passion Fruit Wasabi Mustard

    in stock

    The tropical flavor of real passion fruit in a delicious mustard base accented by wasabi. No wonder it was the Grand Champion at the 2005 World-Wid...

    View full details
  • Original price $19.00 - Original price $19.00
    Original price
    $19.00
    $19.00 - $19.00
    Current price $19.00

    Pommery Gingerbread Mustard

    in stock

    The French love their "Bread of Spices," similar to what we know as gingerbread, and they have made this one of their most unusual flavors for must...

    View full details