Skip to content
Open Daily, 10 AM – 5 PM • Middleton, Wisconsin • 800-438-6878

Current outgoing shipping days are Mon, Tue, Thu, and Fri.
Open Daily, 10 AM – 5 PM • Middleton, Wisconsin •
800-438-6878

Current outgoing shipping days are Mon, Tue, Thu, and Fri.

Specialty Food


Original price $3.75 - Original price $5.25
Original price
$3.75 - $5.25
$3.75 - $5.25
Current price $3.75

East Shore Dipping Pretzels

Only 2 left!

A pretzel is a pretzel is a pretzel, right? Not when it's an East Shore one, designed especially to facilitate your mustard consumption.Ingredients...

View full details
Original price $3.95 - Original price $3.95
Original price
$3.95
$3.95 - $3.95
Current price $3.95

Bucky Badger Pretzel Sticks

in stock

Bucky Badger likes mustard and pretzels — so much that he has his own pretzels. Make sure to buy some good dipping mustards to go with them!Ingredi...

View full details
Original price $3.95 - Original price $3.95
Original price
$3.95
$3.95 - $3.95
Current price $3.95

Bucky Badger Mini Party Pretzel Twists

in stock

A simple and perfect twist for dipping your mustards.Ingredients: Enriched Wheat Flour (Wheat Flour, Niacin, Reduced Iron, Thiamin Mononitrate, Rib...

View full details
Original price $4.25 - Original price $4.25
Original price
$4.25
$4.25 - $4.25
Current price $4.25

Baraboo Candy Milk Chocolate Cow Pie

in stock

Top off your mustard eating with a scrumptious, sweet treat. You'll keep coming back for more of this handmade-in-Wisconsin candy, full of rich cho...

View full details
Original price $10.50 - Original price $10.50
Original price
$10.50
$10.50 - $10.50
Current price $10.50

Stormin' Sauce by Gorman Thomas

Out of stock

Gorman Thomas was the American League home run champ in 1979 and 1982, and he brings his South Carolina roots to Wisconsin with this sassy mustard-...

View full details
Original price $2.95 - Original price $11.50
Original price
$2.95 - $11.50
$2.95 - $11.50
Current price $2.95

Honey Acres Cinnamon Honey Spread

in stock

It's just pure clover honey and cinnamon, but the way our friends at Honey Acres blend these two simple ingredients into this incredible creamy spr...

View full details
Original price $8.95 - Original price $15.95
Original price
$8.95 - $15.95
$8.95 - $15.95
Current price $8.95

Fortune Favors Candied Pecans - The Classic (Formerly Nutkrack)

in stock

From the very first taste, Fortune Favors The Classic captures your senses and takes you on a journey beyond the ordinary. This is more than a cand...

View full details
Original price $5.95 - Original price $19.95
Original price
$5.95 - $19.95
$5.95 - $19.95
Current price $5.95

Wisconsin Natural Acres Honey

in stock

100% natural select premium honey is a delicious and healthy alternative to sugar in your favorite beverages and recipes. Wisconsin Natural Acres c...

View full details
Original price $7.50 - Original price $7.50
Original price
$7.50
$7.50 - $7.50
Current price $7.50

Kathi German Pretzel Mix

in stock

Whip up a batch of authentic Bavarian pretzels with this easy baking mix — simply add water and oil to bring home the soft and chewy taste of Oktob...

View full details
Original price $2.95 - Original price $11.50
Original price
$2.95 - $11.50
$2.95 - $11.50
Current price $2.95

Honey Acres Lemon Honey Spread

in stock

Great on toast, bagels, or English muffins as a perky pick me up. Amazing mixed into any cold or warm tea to add sweetness from the honey and the z...

View full details
Original price $2.95 - Original price $2.95
Original price
$2.95
$2.95 - $2.95
Current price $2.95

Haribo Ginger Lemon

in stock

Wake up your taste buds with these unique HARIBO Ginger-Lemon gummies! The combination of these two distinct flavors creates an irresistible sensat...

View full details
Original price $6.95 - Original price $27.95
Original price
$6.95 - $27.95
$6.95 - $27.95
Current price $6.95

Maple Hollow Pure Maple Syrup

in stock

The Polak family has been making pure maple syrup since 1889 in Merrill, Wisconsin. Three-time First Place Winner of the International Maple Syrup ...

View full details
Original price $1.95 - Original price $1.95
Original price
$1.95
$1.95 - $1.95
Current price $1.95

East Shore Skinny Dipping Pretzels

in stock

These thin salted sticks go with everything! They are a pantry staple and a party essential. Ingredients: Enriched Wheat Flour (Wheat Flour, Niacin...

View full details
Original price $4.25 - Original price $4.25
Original price
$4.25
$4.25 - $4.25
Current price $4.25

Baraboo Candy Peanut Butter Cow Pie

Only 3 left!

Peanut butter fans rejoice! Fresh roasted peanuts covered with signature gourmet caramel, followed by a layer of creamy peanut butter and then smot...

View full details
Original price $3.95 - Original price $3.95
Original price
$3.95
$3.95 - $3.95
Current price $3.95

Honey Acres Clover Honey Baby Bear

in stock

An adorable mini bear filled with Wisconsin-made honey! This clover honey possesses a mild flavor and just enough sweetness, with a floral aftertas...

View full details
Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
Original price
$6.50
$6.50 - $6.50
Current price $6.50

East Shore Mini Mustard and Pretzels Snack Set

in stock

Sweet and Tangy set includes:Sweet & Tangy Mustard (1.4 oz)Seasoned Pretzels (2 oz) Key Lime set includes:Key Lime with Ginger Mustard (1.4 oz)...

View full details
Original price $1.69 - Original price $1.69
Original price
$1.69
$1.69 - $1.69
Current price $1.69

Stonewall Kitchen Maple Brown Butter Waffle Cookie

Out of stock

Traditionally known as stroopwafels, these popular treats from the Netherlands date back to 19th-century Europe. For Stonewall Kitchen's modern tak...

View full details
Original price $11.95 - Original price $11.95
Original price
$11.95
$11.95 - $11.95
Current price $11.95

Rusty Dog Sconnie Blend Coffee

in stock

Our Museum-brand Rusty Dog Sconnie Blend Coffee is the perfect way for you to wake up. This blend is available as whole beans or grounds to give yo...

View full details
Original price $1.95 - Original price $1.95
Original price
$1.95
$1.95 - $1.95
Current price $1.95

Usinger's Beef Hickory Sticks

in stock

Ready to eat, beef summer sausage mini-links. Slim in appearance, huge in flavor. A hint of garlic and a bit of crushed red pepper adds a zesty sur...

View full details
Original price $2.50 - Original price $2.50
Original price
$2.50
$2.50 - $2.50
Current price $2.50

Maple Hollow Maple Sugar Candy Leaves

in stock

Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
Original price
$9.95
$9.95 - $9.95
Current price $9.95

Stonewall Kitchen Sea Salt Caramel Sauce

in stock

Delectably smooth, richly sweet, and unexpectedly captivating with a pop of salty, this caramel sauce takes desserts to a whole new level. Pour it ...

View full details
Original price $7.50 - Original price $7.50
Original price
$7.50
$7.50 - $7.50
Current price $7.50

Maple Hollow Pure Maple Syrup in Leaf Bottle

in stock

This little glass maple leaf full of pure Wisconsin maple syrup makes the perfect gift. Ingredients: Pure Maple Syrup. Kosher

Original price $5.00 - Original price $5.00
Original price
$5.00
$5.00 - $5.00
Current price $5.00

Terrapin Ridge Butter Braided Pretzel Twists

in stock

Light and crispy with just the right amount of buttery flavor, these make a great snacking pretzel. Use with your favorite mustard! Ingredients: Un...

View full details
Original price $10.50 - Original price $10.50
Original price
$10.50
$10.50 - $10.50
Current price $10.50

Stonewall Kitchen Red Raspberry Jam

in stock

Enjoy the tantalizing flavor of sun-ripened raspberries all year long. One taste of this raspberry jam will bring back memories of pick-your-own be...

View full details
Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
Original price
$9.95
$9.95 - $9.95
Current price $9.95

Stonewall Kitchen Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Caramel Sauce

in stock

Artfully crafted, this caramel sauce's unexpected combination of savory and sweet is perfect alone, with ice cream, or on pieces of fruit. Try addi...

View full details
Original price $9.75 - Original price $9.75
Original price
$9.75
$9.75 - $9.75
Current price $9.75

Terrapin Ridge Onion Blossom Horseradish Dip

in stock

A delightful dip for veggies — with just the right amount of kick.ingredients: Soybean Oil, Water, Horseradish Root, Buttermilk, Distilled Vinegar,...

View full details
Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
Original price
$8.95
$8.95 - $8.95
Current price $8.95

Stonewall Kitchen Roasted Garlic Onion Jam

in stock

Garlic and onion as a sweet jam surprise. Incredible on garden-fresh green beans or added to sauce to complement a roast. Try it with cream cheese ...

View full details
Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
Original price
$9.95
$9.95 - $9.95
Current price $9.95

Paradigm Irish Cream Haute Fudge

in stock

Magnificently decadent hot fudge chocolate sauce with a generous addition of Bailey's Irish Cream Liqueur. Warm and pour over ice cream. Simply fab...

View full details
Original price $11.95 - Original price $11.95
Original price
$11.95
$11.95 - $11.95
Current price $11.95

Stonewall Kitchen Blueberry Lemon Mint Mixer

in stock

Surprise your guests with a marvelous mojito, serve up a sassy spritzer or craft your own cocktail creations with this fun and refreshing Blueberry...

View full details
Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
Original price
$6.50
$6.50 - $6.50
Current price $6.50

Sprecher Root Beer BBQ Sauce

in stock

The New York Times did a blind tasting of root beers and Sprecher of Milwaukee came in first. Can you imagine how fabulous a barbecue sauce made wi...

View full details
Original price $2.50 - Original price $5.25
Original price
$2.50 - $5.25
$2.50 - $5.25
Current price $2.50

East Shore Seasoned Pretzels

Out of stock

Not your everyday pretzel. The fresh and appealing flavor from the unique blend of herbs and spices demands a good mustard. Isn't that the whole po...

View full details
Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
Original price
$8.95
$8.95 - $8.95
Current price $8.95

Stonewall Kitchen Wild Maine Blueberry Jam

in stock

Just sweet, intensely flavorful wild Maine blueberries, the right amount of sugar, and a splash of lemon is used to craft this extraordinary jam. P...

View full details
Original price $12.95 - Original price $12.95
Original price
$12.95
$12.95 - $12.95
Current price $12.95

Stonewall Kitchen Truffle Aioli

in stock

Truffles are an extremely rare, aromatic, and delicious member of the fungi family. Able to grow only in certain soil and climate conditions, they ...

View full details
Original price $13.95 - Original price $13.95
Original price
$13.95
$13.95 - $13.95
Current price $13.95

Cuisine Perel Late Harvest Riesling Vinegar

in stock

The natural sweetness of this vinegar comes from grapes harvested late when the sugars have developed to their fullest. Top ice cream or pour over ...

View full details
Original price $6.95 - Original price $18.95
Original price
$6.95 - $18.95
$6.95 - $18.95
Current price $6.95

Wisconsin Natural Acres Raw Honey

in stock

Raw honey has been described as "honey butter" or "crème honey" — a rich, luscious topping to spread on toast, biscuits, bagels, pancakes, or any o...

View full details
Original price $6.25 - Original price $6.25
Original price
$6.25
$6.25 - $6.25
Current price $6.25

Terrapin Ridge Cinnamon Graham Pretzels

in stock

Crispy, crunchy graham and aromatic cinnamon make a perfect snacking pretzel! Great addition to cheese and fruit boards. Eat with dessert dips, cru...

View full details
Original price $10.50 - Original price $10.50
Original price
$10.50
$10.50 - $10.50
Current price $10.50

Brownwood Farms Jalapeño Cherry BBQ Sauce

in stock

The popular Brownwood Farms Cherry BBQ Sauce now has a spicy cousin — Jalapeño Cherry BBQ Sauce. Same rich cherry taste but with a kick. There are ...

View full details
Original price $9.75 - Original price $9.75
Original price
$9.75
$9.75 - $9.75
Current price $9.75

Terrapin Ridge Hatch Chile Cream Cheese Dip

in stock

Prized chiles from Hatch, New Mexico are folded into whipped cream cheese for a rich, delectable dip. Delight your bagels and wraps, whisk into scr...

View full details
Original price $7.95 - Original price $7.95
Original price
$7.95
$7.95 - $7.95
Current price $7.95

Honey Acres Dark Chocolate Raspberry Honey Patties Bag

Out of stock

These dark chocolate honey patties are an amazing flavor combination. This delicious treat is one of a kind! Made with three simple ingredients — p...

View full details
Original price $8.95 - Original price $15.95
Original price
$8.95 - $15.95
$8.95 - $15.95
Current price $8.95

Fortune Favors Candied Pecans - The Spicy (Formerly Nutkrack)

in stock

Crafted with a touch of artistry that borders on alchemy, Fortune Favors The Spicy is an experience unlike any other. Five chilis, each a guardian ...

View full details
Original price $3.25 - Original price $3.25
Original price
$3.25
$3.25 - $3.25
Current price $3.25

Ass Kickin' Habanero Popcorn

in stock

Put a little Ass Kickin' in your favorite movie. This microwave popcorn is seasoned just right with a taste of the southwest. Ingredients: Popcorn,...

View full details
Original price $8.50 - Original price $8.50
Original price
$8.50
$8.50 - $8.50
Current price $8.50

Stonewall Kitchen Spicy Chili Bacon Jam

in stock

Big bold flavors combining three tasty peppers and real bacon. On crackers and cream cheese, on pizza, and blended into mashed potatoes. Wowzers! I...

View full details
Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
Original price
$9.95
$9.95 - $9.95
Current price $9.95

Stonewall Kitchen Basil Pesto Aioli

in stock

It's a classic French "mayo" that's blended with basil pesto to create a deliciously versatile aioli. Delicious on sandwiches, as a dip for crudité...

View full details
Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
Original price
$8.95
$8.95 - $8.95
Current price $8.95

Tillen Farms Bada Bing Cherries

in stock

Burgundy in color and nearly twice the size of maraschinos, bing cherries are known for their concentrated sweetness and vibrant flavor. While usua...

View full details
Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
Original price
$9.95
$9.95 - $9.95
Current price $9.95

Stonewall Kitchen Sriracha Aioli

in stock

If the combination of sun-ripened chilis and garlic sounds good to you, then it may be time to fire up your taste buds. This takes sriracha, a spic...

View full details
Original price $7.95 - Original price $7.95
Original price
$7.95
$7.95 - $7.95
Current price $7.95

Honey Acres Dark Chocolate Orange Honey Patties Bag

Out of stock

These dark chocolate honey patties are a classic flavor combination! They are simple, natural, and have just three delicious ingredients. Made with...

View full details
Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
Original price
$8.95
$8.95 - $8.95
Current price $8.95

Bayfield Apple Butter

in stock

The essence of ripe Wisconsin apples comes in a jar of Bayfield Apple Butter. Made in small batches in the northern part of Wisconsin. Simple, natu...

View full details
Original price $3.75 - Original price $5.25
Original price
$3.75 - $5.25
$3.75 - $5.25
Current price $3.75

East Shore Waffle Pretzels

Only 5 left!

These extra crispy waffle-shaped pretzels are a light and versatile snack that go with everything. Mustard lovers will delight in dipping these pre...

View full details