Skip to content
Open Daily, 10 AM – 5 PM • Middleton, Wisconsin • 800-438-6878
Open Daily, 10 AM – 5 PM • Middleton, Wisconsin •
800-438-6878

Specialty Food


  • Original price $2.25 - Original price $5.25
    Original price
    $2.25 - $5.25
    $2.25 - $5.25
    Current price $2.25

    East Shore Dipping Pretzels

    in stock

    A pretzel is a pretzel is a pretzel, right? Not when it's an East Shore one, designed especially to facilitate your mustard consumption.Ingredients...

    View full details
  • Original price $3.95 - Original price $3.95
    Original price
    $3.95
    $3.95 - $3.95
    Current price $3.95

    Bucky Badger Pretzel Sticks

    in stock

    Bucky Badger likes mustard and pretzels — so much that he has his own pretzels. Make sure to buy some good dipping mustards to go with them!Ingredi...

    View full details
  • Original price $3.95 - Original price $3.95
    Original price
    $3.95
    $3.95 - $3.95
    Current price $3.95

    Bucky Badger Mini Party Pretzel Twists

    in stock

    A simple and perfect twist for dipping your mustards.Ingredients: Enriched Wheat Flour (Wheat Flour, Niacin, Reduced Iron, Thiamin Mononitrate, Rib...

    View full details
  • Original price $4.25 - Original price $4.25
    Original price
    $4.25
    $4.25 - $4.25
    Current price $4.25

    Baraboo Candy Milk Chocolate Cow Pie

    in stock

    Top off your mustard eating with a scrumptious, sweet treat. You'll keep coming back for more of this handmade-in-Wisconsin candy, full of rich cho...

    View full details
  • Original price $1.95 - Original price $1.95
    Original price
    $1.95
    $1.95 - $1.95
    Current price $1.95

    Maple Hollow Maple Sugar Candy Leaves

    in stock

  • Original price $8.95 - Original price $15.95
    Original price
    $8.95 - $15.95
    $8.95 - $15.95
    Current price $8.95

    Fortune Favors Candied Pecans - The Classic

    in stock

    From the very first taste, Fortune Favors The Classic captures your senses and takes you on a journey beyond the ordinary. This is more than a cand...

    View full details
  • Original price $0.95 - Original price $0.95
    Original price
    $0.95
    $0.95 - $0.95
    Current price $0.95

    Abdallah Sea Salt Almond Alligator

    in stock

    Creamy caramel, roasted almonds, dark chocolate, and sea salt combined. This candy is a mix of Abdallah's specialty Alligator candy and sea salt ca...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.25 - Original price $6.25
    Original price
    $6.25
    $6.25 - $6.25
    Current price $6.25

    Terrapin Ridge Cinnamon Graham Pretzels

    in stock

    Crispy, crunchy graham and aromatic cinnamon make a perfect snacking pretzel! Great addition to cheese and fruit boards. Eat with dessert dips, cru...

    View full details
  • Original price $7.50 - Original price $7.50
    Original price
    $7.50
    $7.50 - $7.50
    Current price $7.50

    Kathi German Pretzel Mix

    in stock

    Whip up a batch of authentic Bavarian pretzels with this easy baking mix — simply add water and oil to bring home the soft and chewy taste of Oktob...

    View full details
  • Original price $0.95 - Original price $0.95
    Original price
    $0.95
    $0.95 - $0.95
    Current price $0.95

    Abdallah Cinnamon Churro Toffee

    in stock

    Delicate cinnamon sugar toffee made with the finest ingredients.

  • Original price $6.95 - Original price $27.95
    Original price
    $6.95 - $27.95
    $6.95 - $27.95
    Current price $6.95

    Maple Hollow Pure Maple Syrup

    in stock

    The Polak family has been making pure maple syrup since 1889 in Merrill, Wisconsin. Three-time First Place Winner of the International Maple Syrup ...

    View full details
  • Original price $2.95 - Original price $11.50
    Original price
    $2.95 - $11.50
    $2.95 - $11.50
    Current price $2.95

    Honey Acres Lemon Honey Spread

    in stock

    Great on toast, bagels, or English muffins as a perky pick me up. Amazing mixed into any cold or warm tea to add sweetness from the honey and the z...

    View full details
  • Original price $10.50 - Original price $10.50
    Original price
    $10.50
    $10.50 - $10.50
    Current price $10.50

    Stormin' Sauce by Gorman Thomas

    in stock

    Gorman Thomas was the American League home run champ in 1979 and 1982, and he brings his South Carolina roots to Wisconsin with this sassy mustard-...

    View full details
  • Original price $4.25 - Original price $4.25
    Original price
    $4.25
    $4.25 - $4.25
    Current price $4.25

    Baraboo Candy Green Bay Puddles

    in stock

    Bite-sized pieces of rich milk chocolate, creamy caramel, and fresh peanuts. An avalanche of chocolaty-caramel goodness!Ingredients: Milk Chocolate...

    View full details
  • Original price $0.95 - Original price $0.95
    Original price
    $0.95
    $0.95 - $0.95
    Current price $0.95

    Abdallah Peanut Butter Caramel Crisp

    in stock

    This peanut butter caramel crisp is a delicious mix of peanut butter and creamy caramel. When combined with the finest milk chocolate and crunchy r...

    View full details
  • Original price $7.50 - Original price $7.50
    Original price
    $7.50
    $7.50 - $7.50
    Current price $7.50

    Maple Hollow Pure Maple Syrup in Leaf Bottle

    in stock

    This little glass maple leaf full of pure Wisconsin maple syrup makes the perfect gift. Ingredients: Pure Maple Syrup. Kosher

  • Original price $4.25 - Original price $4.25
    Original price
    $4.25
    $4.25 - $4.25
    Current price $4.25

    Baraboo Candy Peanut Butter Cow Pie

    in stock

    Peanut butter fans rejoice! Fresh roasted peanuts covered with signature gourmet caramel, followed by a layer of creamy peanut butter and then smot...

    View full details
  • Original price $5.95 - Original price $19.95
    Original price
    $5.95 - $19.95
    $5.95 - $19.95
    Current price $5.95

    Wisconsin Natural Acres Honey

    Only 5 left!

    100% natural select premium honey is a delicious and healthy alternative to sugar in your favorite beverages and recipes. Wisconsin Natural Acres c...

    View full details
  • Original price $2.95 - Original price $11.50
    Original price
    $2.95 - $11.50
    $2.95 - $11.50
    Current price $2.95

    Honey Acres Cinnamon Honey Spread

    in stock

    It's just pure clover honey and cinnamon, but the way our friends at Honey Acres blend these two simple ingredients into this incredible creamy spr...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
    Original price
    $8.95
    $8.95 - $8.95
    Current price $8.95

    Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam

    Only 1 left!

    A hint of orange liqueur brings out the cheerfulness of ripe pears, tart cranberries, and sweet raspberries in Stonewall Kitchen's very special jam...

    View full details
  • Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
    Original price
    $9.95
    $9.95 - $9.95
    Current price $9.95

    Paradigm Irish Cream Haute Fudge

    in stock

    Magnificently decadent hot fudge chocolate sauce with a generous addition of Bailey's Irish Cream Liqueur. Warm and pour over ice cream. Simply fab...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
    Original price
    $6.50
    $6.50 - $6.50
    Current price $6.50

    East Shore Mini Mustard and Pretzels Snack Set

    in stock

    Sweet and Tangy set includes:Sweet & Tangy Mustard (1.4 oz)Seasoned Pretzels (2 oz) Key Lime set includes:Key Lime with Ginger Mustard (1.4 oz)...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.25 - Original price $6.25
    Original price
    $6.25
    $6.25 - $6.25
    Current price $6.25

    Terrapin Ridge Chocolate Graham Pretzels

    in stock

    Rich, delicious, slightly sweet flavor of chocolate all wrapped up in a light and crunchy pretzel! Perfect to add to cheese and fruit boards. Use w...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.50 - Original price $8.50
    Original price
    $8.50
    $8.50 - $8.50
    Current price $8.50

    Stonewall Kitchen Spicy Chili Bacon Jam

    in stock

    Big bold flavors combining three tasty peppers and real bacon. On crackers and cream cheese, on pizza, and blended into mashed potatoes. Wowzers! I...

    View full details
  • Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
    Original price
    $9.95
    $9.95 - $9.95
    Current price $9.95

    Stonewall Kitchen Sea Salt Caramel Sauce

    in stock

    Delectably smooth, richly sweet, and unexpectedly captivating with a pop of salty, this caramel sauce takes desserts to a whole new level. Pour it ...

    View full details
  • Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
    Original price
    $9.95
    $9.95 - $9.95
    Current price $9.95

    Stonewall Kitchen Fig & Walnut Butter

    in stock

    This decadently rich fruit butter is the perfect topping for your favorite ice cream, cake, or pastry. For a sumptuous breakfast treat, spoon atop ...

    View full details
  • Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
    Original price
    $9.95
    $9.95 - $9.95
    Current price $9.95

    Stonewall Kitchen Basil Pesto Aioli

    in stock

    It's a classic French "mayo" that's blended with basil pesto to create a deliciously versatile aioli. Delicious on sandwiches, as a dip for crudité...

    View full details
  • Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
    Original price
    $6.50
    $6.50 - $6.50
    Current price $6.50

    Sprecher Root Beer BBQ Sauce

    in stock

    The New York Times did a blind tasting of root beers and Sprecher of Milwaukee came in first. Can you imagine how fabulous a barbecue sauce made wi...

    View full details
  • Original price $11.95 - Original price $11.95
    Original price
    $11.95
    $11.95 - $11.95
    Current price $11.95

    Rusty Dog Sconnie Blend Coffee

    in stock

    Our Museum-brand Rusty Dog Sconnie Blend Coffee is the perfect way for you to wake up. This blend is available as whole beans or grounds to give yo...

    View full details
  • Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
    Original price
    $9.95
    $9.95 - $9.95
    Current price $9.95

    Tillen Farms Bloody Mary Medley

    in stock

    Make your favorite beverage bloody brilliant with this delightful assortment of veggies. Pickled in a tasty mix of vinegar and spices, this medley ...

    View full details
  • Original price $3.95 - Original price $3.95
    Original price
    $3.95
    $3.95 - $3.95
    Current price $3.95

    Honey Acres Clover Honey Baby Bear

    in stock

    An adorable mini bear filled with Wisconsin-made honey! This clover honey possesses a mild flavor and just enough sweetness, with a floral aftertas...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
    Original price
    $8.95
    $8.95 - $8.95
    Current price $8.95

    Dillman Farm Pumpkin Butter

    in stock

    Enjoy the seasonal fall flavor of pumpkin on more of your favorite foods year-round by using this all-natural pumpkin butter. Spread the savory pum...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
    Original price
    $8.95
    $8.95 - $8.95
    Current price $8.95

    Bayfield Apple Butter

    in stock

    The essence of ripe Wisconsin apples comes in a jar of Bayfield Apple Butter. Made in small batches in the northern part of Wisconsin. Simple, natu...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.50 - Original price $8.50
    Original price
    $8.50
    $8.50 - $8.50
    Current price $8.50

    Ass Kickin' Mini Hot Sauce 4-Pack

    in stock

    Four original Ass Kickin' hot sauces in mini bottles. Perfect for a gift or to go in your spice rack. Four 0.75 oz bottles of: Ass Kickin' Original...

    View full details
  • Original price $0.95 - Original price $0.95
    Original price
    $0.95
    $0.95 - $0.95
    Current price $0.95

    Abdallah Peppermint Pattie

    in stock

    This dark peppermint pattie is a delicious chocolate confection, featuring dark chocolate and a cool peppermint center. Gluten-Free

  • Original price $1.95 - Original price $1.95
    Original price
    $1.95
    $1.95 - $1.95
    Current price $1.95

    Usinger's Beef Hickory Sticks

    in stock

    Ready to eat, beef summer sausage mini-links. Slim in appearance, huge in flavor. A hint of garlic and a bit of crushed red pepper adds a zesty sur...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
    Original price
    $8.95
    $8.95 - $8.95
    Current price $8.95

    Tillen Farms Bada Bing Cherries

    in stock

    Burgundy in color and nearly twice the size of maraschinos, bing cherries are known for their concentrated sweetness and vibrant flavor. While usua...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.25 - Original price $8.25
    Original price
    $8.25
    $8.25 - $8.25
    Current price $8.25

    Terrapin Ridge Coconut Curry Aioli Squeeze Garnishing Sauce

    in stock

    An incredible aioli with the aromatic combination of coconut cream and curry. Squeeze this delectable flavor combination on everything including ch...

    View full details
  • Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
    Original price
    $9.95
    $9.95 - $9.95
    Current price $9.95

    Tait Farm Cranberry Chutney

    in stock

    This chutney is a classic that is sweet, savory, and slightly spicy. It is used to enhance poultry dishes and is a terrific addition to a turkey sa...

    View full details
  • Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
    Original price
    $9.95
    $9.95 - $9.95
    Current price $9.95

    Stonewall Kitchen Lemon Herb Aioli

    in stock

    Creamy and versatile, this lemon herb aioli makes a wonderful sauce for all kinds of fish. The bright lemon flavor of the aioli is enhanced with ju...

    View full details
  • Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
    Original price
    $9.95
    $9.95 - $9.95
    Current price $9.95

    Stonewall Kitchen Bloody Mary Mixer

    in stock

    Every Bloody Mary fan favors a twist on this popular morning cocktail. This drink mixer has a subtle kick, a good amount of lemon flavor, and just ...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.50 - Original price $8.50
    Original price
    $8.50
    $8.50 - $8.50
    Current price $8.50

    Frostbite Hot Sauce

    Only 5 left!

    The world's first white hot sauce. This sauce is water soluble — you can add it to any drink to spice it up a couple of notches without adding any ...

    View full details
  • Original price $1.95 - Original price $1.95
    Original price
    $1.95
    $1.95 - $1.95
    Current price $1.95

    East Shore Skinny Dipping Pretzels

    in stock

    These thin salted sticks go with everything! They are a pantry staple and a party essential. Ingredients: Enriched Wheat Flour (Wheat Flour, Niacin...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
    Original price
    $8.95
    $8.95 - $8.95
    Current price $8.95

    Delicae Gourmet Greek Mediterranean Salad Dressing

    Only 5 left!

    This fabulous Mediterranean dressing bursts with flavor, reminding you of the sunny islands of Greece. It's a fantastic accompaniment to your favor...

    View full details
  • Original price $5.00 - Original price $5.00
    Original price
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00

    Terrapin Ridge Butter Braided Pretzel Twists

    in stock

    Light and crispy with just the right amount of buttery flavor, these make a great snacking pretzel. Use with your favorite mustard! Ingredients: Un...

    View full details
  • Original price $8.50 - Original price $8.50
    Original price
    $8.50
    $8.50 - $8.50
    Current price $8.50

    Terrapin Ridge Blueberry Bourbon Pecan Jam

    in stock

    Blueberries bursting with flavor are married with pecans, raisins, cinnamon, and a splash of bourbon, creating a jam that is sure to become your fa...

    View full details
  • Original price $15.95 - Original price $15.95
    Original price
    $15.95
    $15.95 - $15.95
    Current price $15.95

    Yandilla Mustard Seed Oil

    Only 3 left!

    Spicy, delicious Yandilla Mustard Seed Oil has very low erucic acid levels, making it the only FDA-approved food grade mustard seed oil in the Unit...

    View full details
  • Original price $4.95 - Original price $4.95
    Original price
    $4.95
    $4.95 - $4.95
    Current price $4.95

    Usinger's Landjaeger Snack Sticks

    in stock

    This is the traditional German-style "hunter" sausage. Carefully crafted using very coarsely ground pork and beef. Seasoning with garlic, spices, a...

    View full details