Skip to content
Open Daily, 10 AM – 5 PM • Middleton, Wisconsin • 800-438-6878

Current outgoing shipping days are Mon, Tue, Thu, and Fri.
Open Daily, 10 AM – 5 PM • Middleton, Wisconsin •
800-438-6878

Current outgoing shipping days are Mon, Tue, Thu, and Fri.

Toys & Games

Original price $20.00 - Original price $20.00
Original price
$20.00
$20.00 - $20.00
Current price $20.00

White Mountain Puzzles I Love Wisconsin Puzzle

in stock

An amazing 1000-piece puzzle honoring many highlights of the Badger State! Can you find the National Mustard Museum? Bring the whole family togethe...

View full details
Original price $4.00 - Original price $4.00
Original price
$4.00
$4.00 - $4.00
Current price $4.00

Toysmith Key Chain Tape Measure

in stock

This metal tape measures metric and standard and comes attached to a key ring. Features a lock button.

Original price $7.00 - Original price $7.00
Original price
$7.00
$7.00 - $7.00
Current price $7.00

Toysmith Pulled Pork

in stock

A sand-filled stretchy pig for fidgeting and stress relief. Measures 3.5 inches long.

Original price $5.50 - Original price $5.50
Original price
$5.50
$5.50 - $5.50
Current price $5.50

Toysmith Bitty Buddies

in stock

Each tiny animal figurine is made with nontoxic, high-quality plastic and features soft round eyes. Each Bitty Buddies toy comes with its own brigh...

View full details
Original price $3.95 - Original price $3.95
Original price
$3.95
$3.95 - $3.95
Current price $3.95

Toysmith Millennial Mood Ring

in stock

Who has time to talk about their feelings? Most young people are too busy hustling their multiple jobs. The mood ring becomes a mood beacon. Fits m...

View full details
Original price $2.75 - Original price $2.75
Original price
$2.75
$2.75 - $2.75
Current price $2.75

Toysmith Road Trip Bingo

in stock

Each card holds 24 unique slots with one free spot in the middle. Slide the windows closed to mark a spot.

Original price $2.50 - Original price $2.50
Original price
$2.50
$2.50 - $2.50
Current price $2.50

Archie McPhee Rubber Chicken Keyring

in stock

This keyring has the key… to hilarity! Put your keys on a rubber chicken and show the world your sophisticated sense of humor. The bright yellow co...

View full details
Original price $20.00 - Original price $20.00
Original price
$20.00
$20.00 - $20.00
Current price $20.00

White Mountain Puzzles I Love Cheese Puzzle

Only 3 left!

This 1000-piece puzzle features all our favorite cheese snacks. It's sure to make you feel like a big cheese when you complete it.

Original price $4.50 - Original price $4.50
Original price
$4.50
$4.50 - $4.50
Current price $4.50

Toysmith Squishy Kiji Buddy & Slime

in stock

The Squishy Kiji Buddy & Slime kit is packaged in a resealable plastic container. Each one includes 1 mini squishy Kiji animal figure and 2 oun...

View full details
Original price $4.75 - Original price $4.75
Original price
$4.75
$4.75 - $4.75
Current price $4.75

Archie McPhee Happy Axolotl

in stock

Anyone who knows what an axolotl is will want one! These adorable soft vinyl axolotls are 3" long.

Original price $4.50 - Original price $4.50
Original price
$4.50
$4.50 - $4.50
Current price $4.50

Toysmith Kiji Buddy Axolotl and Slime

in stock

The rare and trendy axolotl gets Kiji-fied as an adorably squishy complete with 2 ounces of slime for a tactile multi-sensory experience.

Original price $6.00 - Original price $6.00
Original price
$6.00
$6.00 - $6.00
Current price $6.00

Toysmith Infinite Fidget Cube

in stock

Flip and turn this multicolored puzzle cube for hours of fun. Measures 3.25 inches x 1.50 inches x .75 inches.

Original price $5.25 - Original price $5.25
Original price
$5.25
$5.25 - $5.25
Current price $5.25

Toysmith Kiji Blind Capsule

in stock

What’s inside the capsule? It’s a surprise! Each capsule contains 3 animal squishes (each individually packaged inside the capsule). Animal toys va...

View full details
Original price $20.00 - Original price $20.00
Original price
$20.00
$20.00 - $20.00
Current price $20.00

Please Pass the Mustard Board Game

in stock

It's a game for mustard lovers of all ages. Players try to find five foods and their matching mustards. But you can thwart your opponent (ruin thei...

View full details
Original price $8.50 - Original price $8.50
Original price
$8.50
$8.50 - $8.50
Current price $8.50

Toysmith Daredevil Flyer

in stock

This 7-inch foam flyer soars up to 50 feet and performs aerial stunts when the flaps are bent.

Original price $15.95 - Original price $15.95
Original price
$15.95
$15.95 - $15.95
Current price $15.95

Poupon U Teddy Bear

in stock

Our soft loveable mustard-friendly 10" bear wearing a yellow T-shirt with the official Poupon U logo. Cute, cuddly, and condimentally correct.

Original price $13.95 - Original price $13.95
Original price
$13.95
$13.95 - $13.95
Current price $13.95

Archie McPhee Yodelling Pickle

in stock

It looks like a real pickle, about 5 1/4" long. Press the button and it yodels. Runs on batteries (included) that can be replaced.The yodel goes on...

View full details
Original price $8.50 - Original price $8.50
Original price
$8.50
$8.50 - $8.50
Current price $8.50

Toysmith Classic Notepad Games

in stock

Kids stay engaged and entertained with these timeless games perfect for road tripping siblings. Includes three classic games with 50 pages per game...

View full details
Original price $20.00 - Original price $20.00
Original price
$20.00
$20.00 - $20.00
Current price $20.00

Birch House Living Handcrafted Tic-Tac-Toe Game

Only 4 left!

This travel-sized tic-tac-toe board is a fun gift for families and kids. Every board is handcrafted with two layers of beautiful birch wood and fin...

View full details
Original price $8.00 - Original price $8.00
Original price
$8.00
$8.00 - $8.00
Current price $8.00

Toysmith Aquoddities Squishimals

in stock

This delightful squishy toy is filled with sand offers a unique sensory experience for children, perfect for sparking creativity and encouraging im...

View full details
Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
Original price
$8.95
$8.95 - $8.95
Current price $8.95

Archie McPhee Itty Bitty Rubber Chickens

Only 4 left!

You can never have too many teeny-weeny chickens. Rubber chickens are funny, so that means Itty Bitty Rubber Chickens are not only hilarious, but a...

View full details
Original price $4.95 - Original price $4.95
Original price
$4.95
$4.95 - $4.95
Current price $4.95

Toysmith Dinosaur Fossil Putty

in stock

Stretch it, throw it, stick it, squeeze it — hours of sensory, tactile fun that makes it a popular party favor or goodie bag item. Each putty comes...

View full details
Original price $5.00 - Original price $5.00
Original price
$5.00
$5.00 - $5.00
Current price $5.00

Toysmith Water Arcade Game

in stock

This evergreen game continues to entertain. Add water and push the buttons to score. Measures 3.25 inches tall.

Original price $1.25 - Original price $1.25
Original price
$1.25
$1.25 - $1.25
Current price $1.25

Archie McPhee Pocket Rubber Chicken

Only 4 left!

Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
Original price
$8.95
$8.95 - $8.95
Current price $8.95

Archie McPhee Itty Bitty Axolotls

in stock

A bag of tiny axolotls? This must be heaven! Everyone needs a squad of friends to tell them how smart, good-looking and awesome they are. These bab...

View full details
Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
Original price
$6.50
$6.50 - $6.50
Current price $6.50

Toysmith Kitty Litter

in stock

A sensory combo of squishy and sandy. This laid back kitty is ready for its new home, litter box too. Includes one squishable kitty and 3.5 ounces ...

View full details
Original price $13.95 - Original price $13.95
Original price
$13.95
$13.95 - $13.95
Current price $13.95

Archie McPhee Inflatable Turkey

in stock

Last year we let one of these be the centerpiece of our Thanksgiving meal. The guest said it looked better than the real one we roasted. Bummer. Wh...

View full details
Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
Original price
$9.95
$9.95 - $9.95
Current price $9.95

Mustard Museum Playing Cards

in stock

A standard deck of premium, casino-quality playing cards emblazoned with the Mustard Museum logo. Packaged in a white cardboard box with a clear wi...

View full details
Original price $15.95 - Original price $15.95
Original price
$15.95
$15.95 - $15.95
Current price $15.95

Cow Plush

in stock

Bring some cheesy charm into your life with our Cow Plush! This adorable bovine buddy is made from soft, huggable material and proudly representing...

View full details
Original price $16.50 - Original price $16.50
Original price
$16.50
$16.50 - $16.50
Current price $16.50

Toysmith Mini Zen Garden

in stock

Includes white sand, stones, ceramic figures, and mini rake. Wood tray measures 4 inches x 3 inches.

Original price $6.75 - Original price $6.75
Original price
$6.75
$6.75 - $6.75
Current price $6.75

Toysmith Pig Pen Slime

in stock

Pig Pen Slime contains 2 squishy pink piggies and 1 resealable plastic container of non-toxic brown gooey slime. Kids love the bright pink piglets ...

View full details
Original price $3.00 - Original price $3.00
Original price
$3.00
$3.00 - $3.00
Current price $3.00

Toysmith String Game

Only 3 left!

A fidget game, stress reliever, and fun, hands-on activity for both kids and adults. Each packet includes one multicolored string that can be conto...

View full details
Original price $20.00 - Original price $20.00
Original price
$20.00
$20.00 - $20.00
Current price $20.00

White Mountain Puzzles Things I Ate As A Kid Puzzle

Only 2 left!

Causing sugar overload and making us hungry for more, this 1000-piece puzzle is a colorful jumble of goodies.

Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
Original price
$9.95
$9.95 - $9.95
Current price $9.95

Toysmith Foodie Fleet

in stock

The Foodie Fleet die-cast toy truck from Toysmith comes in 2 fun food themes with colorful designs on each. Choose the ice cream truck or the hot d...

View full details
Original price $13.50 - Original price $13.50
Original price
$13.50
$13.50 - $13.50
Current price $13.50

Archie McPhee Emotional Support Chicken

Only 1 left!

Are you too chicken to be vulnerable? Need a friend? How about an Emotional Support Chicken? We all need someone to lean on, but when you lean on t...

View full details
Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
Original price
$6.50
$6.50 - $6.50
Current price $6.50

Toysmith Unicorn Poop

Only 3 left!

Moldable glittery pink putty. Watch it melt and then re-mold to do again.

Original price $6.00 - Original price $6.00
Original price
$6.00
$6.00 - $6.00
Current price $6.00

Toysmith Butterfly Suprise

Only 3 left!

The Surprise Butterfly practical joke toy is incredibly fun and colorful. Each Surprise Butterfly toy includes two trick butterflies and five rubbe...

View full details
Original price $6.95 - Original price $6.95
Original price
$6.95
$6.95 - $6.95
Current price $6.95

Archie McPhee Bendy Rubber Chicken

in stock

If you’re in search of perfectly pliable poultry to perch precariously on a precipice, this is the product for you! This 5" tall, soft vinyl rubber...

View full details
Original price $5.75 - Original price $5.75
Original price
$5.75
$5.75 - $5.75
Current price $5.75

Toysmith Squishy Unicorn

Only 2 left!

This cute unicorn makes the perfect stocking-stuffer or birthday gift! The squishy unicorn is made of slow rise foam, making it a perfect fidget to...

View full details
Original price $20.00 - Original price $20.00
Original price
$20.00
$20.00 - $20.00
Current price $20.00

Candylab Frank's Hot Dog Van

Only 2 left!

Nothing says NYC like a hot dog stand, the quintessential New York street food. Our hot dog truck is a minimalist, design-focused, vehicular interp...

View full details
Original price $4.95 - Original price $4.95
Original price
$4.95
$4.95 - $4.95
Current price $4.95

Archie McPhee Finger Meerkat

in stock

The meerkat is a small mongoose from Africa. They like to spend a lot of time peering at things with a bit of a smug expression.

Original price $7.95 - Original price $7.95
Original price
$7.95
$7.95 - $7.95
Current price $7.95

Archie McPhee Stress Rubber Chicken

in stock

Regular rubber chickens relieve stress, but this one doubly so! Seeing the dopey look on this rubber chicken’s face is almost as stress-relieving a...

View full details
Original price $20.00 - Original price $20.00
Original price
$20.00
$20.00 - $20.00
Current price $20.00

Candylab Dr. Salty Pretzel Van

Only 3 left!

You’re knot going to be able to resist the new Dr. Salty Van. Trust us, we’re all twisted up over this one. This Dr. Salty Van wouldn’t be right wi...

View full details
Original price $10.00 - Original price $10.00
Original price
$10.00
$10.00 - $10.00
Current price $10.00

Toysmith Magnetic Tic Tac Toe

Only 4 left!

This slim compact game is the perfect travel companion. Each tin is self-contained and includes all game pieces needed for play.

Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
Original price
$8.95
$8.95 - $8.95
Current price $8.95

Toysmith Screamin' Goat

in stock

A hilarious gag gift guaranteed to bring laughter to any occasion. This 9.5" plastic goat is more than meets the eye. Give it a squeeze and be deli...

View full details
Original price $4.95 - Original price $4.95
Original price
$4.95
$4.95 - $4.95
Current price $4.95

Toysmith Fake Moustaches

Only 2 left!

A moust-have item from Little Joker, this fake moustache sticker set is safe for facial use. There are 6 different moustache shapes. One-time use, ...

View full details
Original price $16.95 - Original price $16.95
Original price
$16.95
$16.95 - $16.95
Current price $16.95

Toysmith Magic 8 Ball

in stock

The original Magic 8 Ball has the answers to all of your most pressing questions! This novelty toy offers fortune-telling fun and intrigue for ever...

View full details
Original price $16.00 - Original price $16.00
Original price
$16.00
$16.00 - $16.00
Current price $16.00

Toysmith Bluey Bingo's Bingo

Only 3 left!

Bluey is a loveable, six-year-old Blue Heeler dog, who loves to turn everyday family life into endless, playful adventures. She loves to create and...

View full details