Skip to content
Open Daily, 10 AM – 5 PM • Middleton, Wisconsin • 800-438-6878

Current outgoing shipping days are Mon, Tue, Thu, and Fri.
Open Daily, 10 AM – 5 PM • Middleton, Wisconsin •
800-438-6878

Current outgoing shipping days are Mon, Tue, Thu, and Fri.

Hot Pepper Mustard


Original price $8.50 - Original price $8.50
Original price
$8.50
$8.50 - $8.50
Current price $8.50

Cherchies Hot Banana Pepper Mustard

in stock

Chopped sweet-hot banana peppers make this mustard more like a relish. Delicious on brats, pizza, and Italian panini.Ingredients: Water, Vinegar, B...

View full details
Original price $4.95 - Original price $4.95
Original price
$4.95
$4.95 - $4.95
Current price $4.95

Pacific Farms Japanese Mustard

in stock

Loaded with real wasabi and a seven spice blend, this is what you want for your next sushi plate. Mix it with soy sauce for a spicy sushi dip! Ingr...

View full details
Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
Original price
$8.95
$8.95 - $8.95
Current price $8.95

Dillman Farm Smoky Chipotle Mustard

in stock

A smooth, smoky barbecue sauce flavor with just a touch of heat. Perfect for anything grilled. Ingredients: Mustard (Vinegar, Mustard Seed, Water, ...

View full details
Original price $8.75 - Original price $8.75
Original price
$8.75
$8.75 - $8.75
Current price $8.75

Terrapin Ridge Nashville Hot Spice Mustard

in stock

Cayenne pepper and smoked paprika are a few of the ingredients that give this creamy mustard a kick! This spicy mustard will enliven sandwiches, bu...

View full details
Original price $6.75 - Original price $6.75
Original price
$6.75
$6.75 - $6.75
Current price $6.75

Haus Barhyte Spicy Red Jalapeño Mustard

in stock

A medium-hot mustard with great flavor, perfect for brats and burgers. Ingredients: White Distilled Vinegar, Water, Red and Green Jalapeno Peppers ...

View full details
Original price $6.95 - Original price $6.95
Original price
$6.95
$6.95 - $6.95
Current price $6.95

Slimm & Nunne Habanero Horseradish Mustard

in stock

Ingredients: Water, Red Wine and White Wine Vinegars, Mustard Seed, Honey, Grated Horseradish Roots, White Wine, Salt, Habanero Peppers, Sugar, Soy...

View full details
Original price $12.95 - Original price $12.95
Original price
$12.95
$12.95 - $12.95
Current price $12.95

Burnt & Salty Korean Mustard

in stock

Congratulations on discovering one of the most unique, versatile condiments on the market. Perk up your sandwiches, eggs, and pizza. Keep it close,...

View full details
Original price $5.95 - Original price $5.95
Original price
$5.95
$5.95 - $5.95
Current price $5.95

Plochman's Cuban Style Mustard

in stock

A hint of garlic, a touch of citrus, and white wine give this yellow mustard a unique Cuban-style flavor. Use it to add spice to roast pork sandwic...

View full details
Original price $6.95 - Original price $6.95
Original price
$6.95
$6.95 - $6.95
Current price $6.95

Inglehoffer Ghost Pepper Mustard

in stock

Gold medal winner at the 2016 and 2017 World-Wide Mustard Competition in the Hot Pepper category. Deservedly so. This is some serious pain. You've ...

View full details
Original price $7.95 - Original price $7.95
Original price
$7.95
$7.95 - $7.95
Current price $7.95

Maison Louisianne Creole Mustard

in stock

You won't find a better Creole-style mustard anywhere! Use it as a dip for fresh vegetables, with oil and vinegar as a salad dressing, or as a ligh...

View full details
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95

Fat Crow Horseradish and Pepper Mustard

in stock

This award-winning gourmet mustard combines a trifecta of spicy pepper with the potent flavor of horseradish. Stir, then spread or dip! Bronze meda...

View full details
Original price $19.00 - Original price $19.00
Original price
$19.00
$19.00 - $19.00
Current price $19.00

Pommery Moutarde des Pompiers (Firemen's Mustard)

in stock

From the venerable moutardier Pommery comes this spicy Fireman's Mustard — Moutarde des Pompiers. The French don't often use hot peppers in their m...

View full details
Original price $6.95 - Original price $6.95
Original price
$6.95
$6.95 - $6.95
Current price $6.95

Inglehoffer Sweet-Hot Pepper Mustard

in stock

A brightly flavored hot pepper mustard. Bronze medal winner at the 2016 World-Wide Mustard Competition.Ingredients: Water, Mustard Seed, Sugar, Pep...

View full details
Original price $4.50 - Original price $8.95
Original price
$4.50 - $8.95
$4.50 - $8.95
Current price $4.50

Sutter Buttes Jalapeño Whiskey Mustard

in stock

With a hint of whiskey and a clear jalapeño flavor, this gold medal winner is medium-hot but loaded with flavor. It's a little sweet, a little hot,...

View full details
Original price $6.95 - Original price $6.95
Original price
$6.95
$6.95 - $6.95
Current price $6.95

Inglehoffer Extra Hot Sriracha Mustard

in stock

Gold medal winner in the pepper hot category at the 2015 and 2014 World-Wide Mustard Competition. Not just big heat but big flavor, too. Blend some...

View full details
Original price $5.50 - Original price $5.50
Original price
$5.50
$5.50 - $5.50
Current price $5.50

Lakeside's Jalapeño Mustard

Only 1 left!

Tangy yellow mustard with the bite and burn of jalapeño. Ingredients: Distilled Vinegar, Mustard Seed, Salt, Turmeric, Paprika, Jalapeño Peppers, S...

View full details
Original price $9.50 - Original price $9.50
Original price
$9.50
$9.50 - $9.50
Current price $9.50

Daddy Cook's Heaven 'N Hell Mustard

in stock

Silver medal winner in the Pepper Hot category at the 2012 World-Wide Mustard Competition. Great heat and sweet rolled into one satisfying mustard ...

View full details
Original price $28.00 - Original price $28.00
Original price
$28.00
$28.00 - $28.00
Current price $28.00

Hot Pepper Trio Gift Box

In stock

Bring the heat and expand your horizons as an adventurous chef with this hot pepper gift set. Enclosed in Gift Box:Cherchies Hot Banana Pepper Must...

View full details
Original price $6.95 - Original price $6.95
Original price
$6.95
$6.95 - $6.95
Current price $6.95

Gator Hammock Swamp Mustard

Only 5 left!

Sweet and tangy, this mustard is blended with tropical guavas, red cider vinegar, and a special blend of spices. Adds spark to most any dish. Very ...

View full details
Original price $5.95 - Original price $5.95
Original price
$5.95
$5.95 - $5.95
Current price $5.95

Plochman's Chili Dog Mustard

in stock

This chili-flavored mustard made by the world famous Plochman's company turns your hot dog into a chili dog with a squeeze of the bottle. Ingredien...

View full details
Original price $5.95 - Original price $5.95
Original price
$5.95
$5.95 - $5.95
Current price $5.95

Plochman's Chicago Fire Mustard

in stock

Fire things up with the flavor of a peppery hot sauce and put a little spice into every bite of this saucy mustard creation. Ingredients: White Dis...

View full details
Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
Original price
$9.95
$9.95 - $9.95
Current price $9.95

Tait Farm Mango Habanero Mustard

Only 1 left!

A collision of tropical fruit and the fiery Latin American habanero pepper. This hot-sweet mustard brings a blast of flavor to your summer barbecue...

View full details
Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
Original price
$8.95
$8.95 - $8.95
Current price $8.95

Galena Raspberry Habanero Honey Mustard

in stock

Nicely sweet with all the heat! If you love an extra kick in your mustard, this is it. Try it on grilled meat or just for dipping. Ingredients: Bro...

View full details
Original price $5.95 - Original price $5.95
Original price
$5.95
$5.95 - $5.95
Current price $5.95

Zatarain's Creole Mustard

in stock

The classic New Orleans Creole mustard — an absolute essential for making authentic remoulade sauce. Great for deli sandwiches, to. Ingredients: Vi...

View full details
Original price $7.95 - Original price $7.95
Original price
$7.95
$7.95 - $7.95
Current price $7.95

Paradigm Jalapeño Stout Mustard

Only 3 left!

An awesome spicy beer mustard from the great Northwest.Ingredients: Distilled Vinegar, Water, Mustard Seed, Jalapeno Peppers, Oregon Stout Beer (Wa...

View full details
Original price $10.95 - Original price $10.95
Original price
$10.95
$10.95 - $10.95
Current price $10.95

Minorcan Mike's Datil Pepper Mustard

in stock

This sweet and spicy mustard is great on sandwiches, hot dogs and burgers, pretzels, BBQ and much more! Ingredients: Mustard (Vinegar, Mustard Seed...

View full details
Original price $3.95 - Original price $3.95
Original price
$3.95
$3.95 - $3.95
Current price $3.95

Silver Spring Chipotle Mustard

in stock

Smoky chipotle adds extra heat to this spicy brown mustard. A wonderful compliment to any sandwich or hot dog. Try stirring it into soups and chili...

View full details
Original price $8.25 - Original price $8.25
Original price
$8.25
$8.25 - $8.25
Current price $8.25

Raye's Haba Habanero Mustard

in stock

One of our hottest pepper mustards! Spice up your chicken, invigorate your egg rolls, or add some zest to your veggies. The smoky heat builds on yo...

View full details
Original price $8.95 - Original price $8.95
Original price
$8.95
$8.95 - $8.95
Current price $8.95

Mucky Duck Hotter Than Mustard

in stock

Mucky Duck cranked up their OG recipe to create a mustard that'll make you sweat. So go ahead and add some 'oomph' to your day. Ingredients: Apple ...

View full details
Original price $7.95 - Original price $7.95
Original price
$7.95
$7.95 - $7.95
Current price $7.95

Old Pecos Foods Green Chile Mustard

Only 5 left!

Ingredients: Distilled White Vinegar, Water, Wheat Flour, Sea Salt, Green Chili Pepper, Ground Mustard, Ground Turmeric. Sugar-Free

Original price $60.00 - Original price $60.00
Original price
$60.00
$60.00 - $60.00
Current price $60.00

Flamin' Flavors Gift Box

In stock

Bring the heat with a fiery assortment of mustards that pack a punch. Enclosed in Gift Box:Minorcan Mike's Datil Pepper MustardInglehoffer Ghost Pe...

View full details
Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
Original price
$9.95
$9.95 - $9.95
Current price $9.95

Butterfly Bakery Maple Sriracha Mustard

in stock

Eastman Long & Son's maple syrup, Vermont garlic scapes and Vermont jalapeños. This is excellent on sandwiches, burgers and fancy cheese. Ingre...

View full details
Original price $6.75 - Original price $6.75
Original price
$6.75
$6.75 - $6.75
Current price $6.75

Saucy Mama Chipotle Mustard

in stock

The chipotle pepper is, of course, a smoked jalapeño, and this mustard lets it shine. An excellent mustard for tacos or burgers.Ingredients: White ...

View full details
Original price $9.95 - Original price $9.95
Original price
$9.95
$9.95 - $9.95
Current price $9.95

Butterfly Bakery Gustard: A Guster Mustard

in stock

Butterfly Bakery made this spicy pickle mustard in collaboration with the musical awesomeness that is Guster. This is a garlic, dill, jalapeño, and...

View full details
Original price $4.95 - Original price $4.95
Original price
$4.95
$4.95 - $4.95
Current price $4.95

Koops' Arizona Heat Mustard

in stock

As red as the sun-soaked rocks of the southwest, this mustard brings bold flavor to a new frontier. Made with an innovative blend of peppers and mu...

View full details
Original price $6.95 - Original price $6.95
Original price
$6.95
$6.95 - $6.95
Current price $6.95

Weber's Jalapeño Mustard

in stock

Weber's Jalapeño Mustard is a fresh tasting smooth yellow mustard with the addition of jalapeño powder and diced jalapeño to ensure a lasting bite....

View full details